Myron Neth responds to Cathy Rinehart’s Assessor letter

Posted: February 5, 2011 in Clay County Politicians in the News
Tags: , , ,

I have not had the time to respond to this, but our Assessor Cathy Rinehart sent you a letter trying to act as an activist with regards to your property taxes a couple of weeks ago. She proposed two changes to Missouri law, neither of which make great sense. I received a communication from State Rep. Myron Neth’s office on the matter and thought I would post it instead of a lengthy diatribe on the topic. We all know I have one in me.

Recently, the Clay County Assessor, Cathy Rinehart, sent out a letter regarding the way vehicles are assessed. She brought up two options that were distinct and separate, but many have thought to be tied together – they are not.  In addition, the issue she raised has nothing to do with any recent change in the law.  The existing statute has been on the books for several years, so the implication that lawmakers have done anything to cause this through recent legislation is false.

Many have raised the concern that this is a back door tax increase.  I fight every day to keep taxes low so I am very sensitive to this accusation. Any increases, however slight, would be due to a used car market that has caused some cars to be valued slightly higher than they might have been in the previous years.  Increased valuation is NOT across the board and depends on your vehicle.  Although perhaps counter-intuitive, in the current market, some used cars might show a higher value, but most will not.  It is not unlike one’s home appreciating in value.  Admittedly, we are much more used to a rising housing market, not a rising auto market. However, should there be a rise in value, it is most likely an anomaly due to the current economic environment.

In regards to the Assessor’s first suggestion of changing the statute language to “may” and having the ability to use the Kelly Blue book value, I have a few concerns.  I am opposed to language that gives too much discretion to any government official or agency.  By using the word “may” instead of “shall”, it leaves a lot of room for subjectivity.  For this reason, I am opposed to the change in language.  Upon further research, I found the Assessor actually has discretion within the current system.  The NADA valuation book offers three choices of value: Clean, Average and Rough.  In one example I researched, a 2006 truck had a $3500 difference between the Clean and Rough values.  So a question arises as to which value the Assessor is using in the calculation.

I am adamantly opposed to the Assessor’s second suggestion of using weight as the determining factor for property tax.  This would greatly discriminate against those with older vehicles, businesses with trucks and the like. In effect, the taxes you pay on your vehicle would never go down.

Some options I am discussing with fellow legislators are to forbid any personal property to be assessed higher than the year prior, require the Assessor to print the value assessed (it is not currently published on tax bills), and allow for an appeal process on the valuation of your automobile.

Here in Jefferson City, I am working with the rest of the Clay County delegation to determine the most appropriate course of action that is in the best interest of taxpayers statewide.  I hope this feedback and response is helpful and we can work together to make sure there is accountability and transparency in all of government.

Representative Myron Neth Thank you again for contacting my office.  I will continue to do everything in my power to improve the quality of life for the citizens of the 34th district and Missouri.  If you have any questions, please do not hestitate to contact my office.

State Representative Myron Neth

34th District

Office phone:  (573) 751-1218


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Andrew, ConservativeElephant. ConservativeElephant said: RT @claycopolitics: Myron Neth responds to Cathy Rinehart's Assessor letter […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s